With the application spectrum for EVV in mobile health care expanding rapidly, Bill Mahon, the
keynote speaker at Tellus’ 2019 eVVolution Summit went old school and brought participants
back to health care delivery’s original sin: fraud, waste and abuse (FWA).
Mahon, President, Mahon Consulting Group, is a widely-recognized expert on U.S. health care
fraud detection, management and prevention strategies and services for domestic and
international health insurance payers, law enforcement agencies and industry organizations.
Mahon reinforced the widely held opinion that EVV — a mobile system that electronically
verifies a caregiver is physically at a patient’s home or location — is an effective weapon in the
government’s arsenal fighting FWA in the Medicaid arena.
FWA was included in the 21 st Century Cures Act, passed by Congress in 2016 to combat
Medicaid billing fraud and other organized schemes that disadvantage both patients and the
health care system at large.
Fueling the regulatory fire was a GAO report that revealed 3 to 10 percent of taxpayer dollars is
lost in the health care system nationally each year as a result of fraud — a number that is even
higher in South Florida and California, Mahon said.
A novel idea
The government’s idea was to use money saved from the use of EVV technology as a result of
reductions in fraud, waste and abuse to help fund innovations for a number of popular health
care initiatives. Personal care services are particularly worrisome for The Centers for Medicare
& Medicaid Services (CMS), because care-giving services are often delivered by family members
or those closest to the patient without proper oversight.
Federally mandated deadlines to implement EVV are set for January 2020 for personal care
services and January 2023 for home health services.
A panel presentation at Tellus’ inaugural EVV national summit last year highlighted the scope of
the problem, noting that federal data showed $29.1 billion in improper Medicaid payments for
personal care services in 2015. That number was up by a wide margin from $14.4 billion in
2013, resulting in more than 200 investigations of billing fraud, organized schemes, deaths and
While [fraud] is an exception, “it’s an unfortunate reality” and a financial drain on the system,
Mahon said, adding that it’s important to draw the distinction between fraud, waste and
abuse in the context of criminal liability. Only fraud can be prosecuted criminally. Abuse must
be intentional, and often “goes up to the line but doesn’t cross it.”
Hot button issue
FWA is so out of control that the acronym has become part of the vernacular for the federal
centers for Medicare and Medicaid services. The agency even uses it in its training manuals for
employees, according to an April 2019 article on Politifact.com.
Fraud prosecutions are ramping up. With the Department of Justice (DOJ) taking the lead on
general health care fraud and the Department of Health and Human Service (HHS) and Office of
Inspector General (OIG) spearheading personal and home health care fraud and abuse
prosecutions. Fraudsters can be sentenced from 20 years to life, in some cases, depending on
whether a death was involved.
The number of recent criminal cases brought by the DOJ, HHS and OIG underscores the
aggressive stand the Feds are taking with the issue. Law.com reported June 20, 2019, 35
criminal and civil fraud settlements with Medicare and Medicaid providers in the first 24 days of
Billing fraud, including services never delivered, unnecessary services or overuse of services,
and upcoding of services is the most common cause of enforcement actions.
“What we’ve seen in recent years is organized criminal activity in the field,” said Mahon,
adding that investigators are always “two steps behind” fraud purveyors in the system. “They
know exactly what they are doing and how to do it.”
Emerging technology like EVV is helping address and mitigate that, he said.
“EVV is certainly a valid and very substantial contribution to the integrity and the efficiency of
The road ahead
Like their investigative counterparts, regulatory agencies continue to combat Medicaid FWA
across the nation.
CMS recently doubled down on its efforts to ensure Medicaid program integrity. On June 19,
2019, CMS issued a news release with renewed guidance, following up on its June 2018
initiative to improve transparency and accountability, strengthen data and utilize innovative
and robust analytic tools.
CMS also said it aims to reduce Medicaid improper payments across states to protect taxpayer
dollars while enhancing the financial and programmatic integrity of the Medicaid program.
Still, it remains an uphill fight, Mahon said. New schemes, violations of the anti-kickback
statute, shady medical equipment telemarketers and the growing opioid crisis are propelling
new cases of fraud forward.
So what’s next on the fraud-fighting horizon?
One viable solution is the detection of suspected fraud before any payment is made, rather
than the “pay and chase” model historically used, Mahon said.
“EVV is clearly a very practical and effective solution to dealing with certain types of claims that
have been problematic in the past,” he said.